2012 May 23 |
 |

— Comment #108411 by Patrick Glenn and replies
Progressives Right On Immigration
Article Page

http://www.theatlanticright.com/social/patrick-glenn/2010/01/07/progressives-right-on-immigration/108411/
0
0
  1. Patrick Glenn jhimmi: thanks for the link to the Heritage Foundation article. It makes several compelling points, which might help to close the theoretical gaps for people like me - classical liberals who are philosophically inclined toward a very open immigration policy but who have concerns about how another amnesty would play out in reality (and on the heels of decades of cynical, scatter-shot immigration policies and enforcement). Unfortunately, immigration does not happen in a vacuum. One interesting section from the article: "While most open-border libertarians proclaim a desire to dismantle both borders and the welfare state, in practice what they offer is open borders today and a vague (and almost certainly illusory) promise to end the welfare state in the indefinite future. As Milton Friedman understood, open-border enthusiasts have the sequence wrong: Opening borders with the redistributionist state still intact will result in a larger and more confiscatory government."