2012 May 23 |
 |
http://www.theatlanticright.com/2010/05/21/help-me-out-here-why-couldnt-we-shut-the-well-from-the-beginning/
0
0
  |   7 comments

I don’t think it’s an understatement to say that the Deepwater Horizon oil spill has turned out to be an environmental disaster unlike we’ve seen in some time.  Today the news came in: There’s more oil coming from the underwater gusher than originally estimated.  And nobody has a clue how much (so says BP).  Meanwhile, oil has reached the Louisiana marshes.  Just look at the picture in that article.  Bobby Jindal looks livid.  Or maybe it’s me that’s feeling livid and I’m just projecting my feelings on to him.  Take your pick.

So, we have that pipe in now, but not only is oil still escaping into the waters (we knew this already), it may be as much or more than it being pumped up to the ships above.

So why is it that BP didn’t try to seal this thing shut from the beginning?  It’s the solution that practically nobody has talked about (aside from the golf ball idea), and yet it’s one that been nagging on my mind for some days now.  I wondered if it might have something to do with the pressure, but that can’t possibly be it, as they’ve got plans to seal it up as soon as next week.

What am I missing here?  It’s now likely that more than 200,000 gallons of oil have been flowing into our water for a month.  Was containment the best option, or could more effort have been taken to completely stop all flow?  I don’t know, but from what I’ve seen, the containment plan has been only just short of a complete failure.  But maybe I’m wrong.  If there are any readers from the oil industry, I’d love to know if I’m wrong, and if so, why.  You can be sure it’ll end up in this spot.

Even if I am wrong, these are questions our leaders in Washington ought to be asking, but they’ve apparently not had the time to do it.

Meanwhile, someone want to explain what’s going on in the video below?  Since when does BP get to make the rules for a public beach?  And since when is the Coast Guard subordinate to a corporation?  A foreign-owned corporation at that.


Watch CBS News Videos Online

  1. Posted by Interested
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #110895
    Interested from my understanding, the original dome was intended to basically place a funnel over the leak and allow the oil to be a controlled evacuation. That failed. To inject the kill mud, they have been drilling a separate well who's sole purpose is to inject the mud and hopefully seal the two leaks, but until they could complete the new wells they also pursued containment - which has been like bailing a 20 foot leaky rowboat with a soup can.
    • Michael_Merritt They must be drilling more than one new well, then, because I thought that was to relieve the pressure from the other fissures. In any case, I was under the impression that it would not be completed for some time. But now they're saying they might have this fixed as early as next week? Something doesn't compute here.
      which has been like bailing a 20 foot leaky rowboat with a soup can
      See, now you have me envisioning BP down there trying to scoop up the oil with soup cans. By which I mean to say: if there are any comic artists that read this blog, draw it and you'll receive a lot of promotion for your website.
      • Posted by Interested
        | Quote | Trackback | Link #110897
        Interested yea we don't exactly have all the information from BP. I know they were doing one or two relief wells to relieve the pressure and allow the two leaking ones to be sealed with cement. But I believe the kill shot is it's own little well intersecting. oh wait, just found this link http://www.necn.com/05/16/10/BP-siphons-oil-from-... I dunno how well it's going to work going against the flow of oil.
  2. Posted by Lee Thomas
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #110979
    Lee Thomas I have a post at my site on the basics of the Deepwater Horizon. But let me try to explain what happened here. BP had just struck a 100,000,000 bbl oil find and were in the process of putting casing into the well to seal it up until they could figure out how to best develop the field. The deepwater horizon is a well drilling vessel. It is not a oil field producing vessel. During the day in question the BOP or blow out preventer was tested repeatedly during the day leading up to the event. It seemed to have failed its pressure tests. A BOP is a device that weights in this case about 400,000 lbs. It has 4 dual pistions that are horizontal to the shaft coming out of the ground. When activated a piston will slide into place sealing the shaft and prevent any oil from escaping to the surface. If their is a severe problem and this one does not seat properly then a second set of pistons will slam shut with incredible force. This large piston will sever the pipe and seal the shaft and prevent the oil or gas from rising up the tube. In this case the Deepwater Horizon was drilling in 5000 feet of water with 5000 feet of 21 inch riser pipes reaching from the surface and connected to the BOP on the ocean floor sitting on top of the drilling hole into the sea bed. Each of these risers are tested to 3.5 million pounds of load bearing capacity and are bolted together with bolts the size of paint cans. They are lowered down and another 90 foot section is bolted into place until they reach the BOP on the surface floor. Now in the case of the Deepwater Horizon......the testing that was taking place just prior to the Blow out was most likely now to blame for the accident. The pistons were failing to seat and so they had a test piston in place that was designed to find out why the piston was not sealing. They had apparently reduced the mud in the tube....mud and water is the sole means for preventing a blow back......this reduction in mud was designed to test the seal on the BOP to make sure that it was working properly. As they reduced the mud it put more and more pressure on the seal and test piston that was in place for testing. The BOP failed and the resulting rise of methane roared up the riser. As the methane rose up the rise forcing mud and water back onto the drilling deck the engineer on duty would have seen the mud flowing back out of the drilling hole and realized immediately that the BOP had to be activated. I have no doubt that the enigneer flipped what amounted to a hydraulic switch to activate the BOP on the sea bed before. The problem is that by flipping the switch the BOP did not activate. That of course is the question on everyones mind. WHY...did it not activate. This Cameron designed BOP was not equipted with an acoustic switch and all BOP's are designed with a deadmans switch that as a last resort if everyones dead or unable to flip the hydraulic BOP that it will flip itself as it reads immense pressures in the riser and works on its own. It all failed. Why is the question. It now appears that the BOP might have been improperly installed and though testing in the past showed it would work properly when tested, the deeper they drilled and the higher the pressures encountered they were starting to have troubles with getting the test piston to seal when tested. Hope this helps you to understand. This is light crude. It biodegrades. This is not the same type of oil that the Exxon Valdez had let loose. Most of this oil will never be cleaned up and in fact will biodegrade on its own. A real plus for this crisis. Additionally something to keep in mind...........this is not the first event like this in the GULF. A blowout on the Ixtoc I rig in 1979 off the coast of Mexico spilled 33,000 barrels of oil a day, threatened the coast of Texas, and took nine months to contain. Technologies and techniques for containing oil spills have improved since then, but challenges have also increased. We survived just fine folks because this IS light sweet crude which biodegrades.
    • Michael_Merritt Thanks, Lee. This was very informative. However, your attempts to reassure will likely fall on deaf ears. This is hardly an economy where gulf fishermen want to see themselves out of work. Some scientists are studying the effect of the dispersants, to see if they're affecting the ability for microbes to biodegrade the oil. Of course, even if they are, there wasn't another realistic course of action. "Just wait for it to break down" would have been met with a mob of out-of-work, torch and pitchfork carrying fishermen.
  3. Pingback | Link #111384
    The Federal Response to the Oil Spill is a Disaster in Itself, But There is Hope [...] indifferent, those on the front lines, like the Coast Guard, seem to be completely crippled.  I touched on this last week when I shared a video from CBS News, where the Coast Guard asked a reporter and her crew to leave a [...]