2012 May 22 |
 |
http://www.theatlanticright.com/2010/03/30/david-swindle-the-books-that-change-us/
0
0

FrontPage Magazine published a follow-up to David Swindle’s article of yesterday, about the indoctrination of America’s college students. Like the first part of this article, I advise you to read it. It’s a bit long, yes, but it’s well worth your time.

David first explains how and why he turned his back on the progressive ideology he held dear in college and before:

Any journey from Left to Right is going to follow two related, parallel paths. One is based on experiences and life events which challenge the “progressive” world view. The second is formed by way of an intellectual journey through key texts which provide for more accurate explanations of reality.

He continues:

I took deeply seriously my father’s suggestion to “take the professor, not the course” — sound advice for any college student. In my literary courses I made a conscious decision to take every class I could taught by Dr. Pat Collier, a specialist in British Modernism — the works of T.S. Eliot, James Joyce, Virginia Woolf, E.M. Forster and other authors from 1890-1940. The principle lesson that I formulated from my engagement with this literature was this: life is complicated, multiple perspectives on the world are vital, no one knows everything. Joyce’s Ulysses, the magnum opus of Modernism, is written not with a single all-knowing narrator but with dozens (hundreds?) of voices. We see how overwhelmingly complex just a single day in Dublin on June 16, 1904 can be. The universe is too big for us to truly grasp. In Woolf’s novels the view peered inward into the infinity of individual minds. Yet we think we can effectively legislate a better world into existence? We think we’re able to plan utopia in a world of limitless variables?

He also changed, he explains, because of something called life. Socialist ideas may sound good (to some, at least), in theory, but those of us who actually live in the real world realize that they can never be implemented successfully because man is a flawed being. We are selfish, greedy and lazy. In other words, “we are broken.”

And that’s only the beginning. There’s much more food for thought in the article. David also explains, for instance, how he became a hawk on foreign policy and the War on Terror (or Islamic extremism); how he came to support Israel unconditionally; how we can make the world a better place “one person at a time,” and, finally, how we can “improve” the “corporate order” not “through a change in government and a restriction of freedom, but in a transition of culture to rebalance economies so that both local and international commerce can thrive.” Read the whole thing here.

  1. Posted by DavidSwindle
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #110304
    DavidSwindle Thanks Michael!
    • Posted by Patrick Glenn
      | Quote | Trackback | Link #110312
      Patrick Glenn David, both posts - parts 1 & 2 - are excellent. I can relate to many of your experiences.
  2. Posted by Lee Thomas
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #110305
    Lee Thomas There is an old saying. Liberals become conservatives when they grow up, get a job and start paying taxes. If that were so then none of what is happening would be happening. Unfortunately for the Right, there is much good to embrace in the left. The left is not evil. They are not radicals. They are simply people who have found what works for them in life. The evil that permeates the left is the progressive movement that is steeped in lies, deception and misdirection. A movement that the word hate cannot even be used to adequately describe their loathing of Corporations and big business. It is this hatred for big business that has kept the unemployment rate hovering near 10 percent because in their hearts they cannot bring themselves to give the breaks to businesses that would bring the unemployment rate down. Our indicators are moving in positive directions except for unemployment. Big Business understands their hatred for them and hence they are not creating new jobs. As corporations have recently reported the cost of this health care bill will prevent them from hiring back any and all employees that were lost due to the recession. I can only attribute their hatred for Corporations in much the same way as the right hates abortion. We could not expect the right to condone or legislate abortion into our national identity anymore then we can expect the progressive left to condone or legislate breaks for businesses into our national identity. In a progressive world get used to 10 percent unemployment going even higher because their absolute hatred for corporations and big business will never allow them to do anything to create jobs other then one bill after another that expands government and creates more government jobs. The Journey to the dark side is complete when you become a progressive. You are not a bad person when you are a progressive you simply are diametrically opposed to what America was for 200 years. The battle is for what it will be the next 200 years. I have a post at my website about what the progressive movement stands for and their historical expansion in America. Worth a read to understand the progressive mind.
    • Posted by Patrick Glenn
      | Quote | Trackback | Link #110310
      Patrick Glenn Lee, I agree with you that the left is not "evil" in general and share many of your concerns about 21st century "progressivism". Most people have good intentions, even if they tend to go about achieving those intentions in counter-productive ways. However, we should keep in mind that many leftists who now refer to themselves as "progressives," previously regarded themselves as "liberals" or "socialists." It is usually quite a bit more complicated than saying that the "progressives" are the bad side of the left, while the other segments are okay. Depends on the individual. For the most part, they're all promoting some bad ideas, although some individuals are more honest, reasonable, fair-minded than others (and that goes for both sides, up to a point).
      • Posted by Lee Thomas
        | Quote | Trackback | Link #110314
        Lee Thomas Interesting that you point that out Patrick. I have a couple posts up at my blog about over 74 members of congress belonging to the Democratic Socialist of America organization. Even during times in which the claim by the right is that our government is trying to take us more progressively left there continues to be denials of such while right under our noses we find that even in schools now the YSA is recruiting and hold socialist rallies in our public schools.
  3. Posted by Evil
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #110319
    Evil The fact that humans are "broken" (perfectly true, although none of us are capable of explaining "whole" as an opposite of "broken" in this regard) works as much against right-wing ideation and societal ideals as the equivalents on the left, of course.
  4. Pingback | Link #110321
    Tweets that mention PoliGazette » David Swindle: The Books that Change Us -- Topsy.com [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mon. Mon said: One Stop Book Stop David Swindle: The Books that Change Us: A movement that the word hate cannot ev... http://bit.ly/aT8Bj8 mybookstop.info [...]
  5. Pingback | Link #110323
    Tweets that mention PoliGazette » David Swindle: The Books that Change Us -- Topsy.com [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Mon. Mon said: One Stop Book Stop David Swindle: The Books that Change Us: A movement that the word hate cannot ev... http://bit.ly/bHKLdZ mybookstop.info [...]
  6. Michael_Merritt One of my favorite political science professors in college was a die-hard liberal, and openly admitted this. Yet, he would always use statistics from the CATO Institute. Sounds like he is at least somewhat like one of Swindle's descriptions of a good professor. Then I took a Native American studies class, and the professor there was not only die-hard, but of the hard indoctrination type. One of my fellow class mates couldn't take it and dropped the course after the first class. I battled through it, but cringed half the time. Ironically, one of the books we were required to read I liked the most out of all of them because it was the least judgmental one.