2012 Feb 6 |
 |
http://www.theatlanticright.com/2009/04/13/obama-tougher-than-credited-for/
0
0

That is at least the impression I got from this AP article. In short: President Obama twice authorized the military to use force against the pirates who had taken captain Richard Phillips hostage. After the second approval, Navy Seals (finally) went in, killed three of the pirates, wounded one, and freed the American hostage.

Administration officials told the news organization that has declared war on the New Media that Obama first gave permission for a rescue operation Friday evening. He upgraded it at 9.20 AM Saturday.

As said in the headline, Obama has proved to be tougher than most gave him credit for. Well done.

Writing for Blue Crab Boulevard, Gaius points out that the article makes clear that Obama and his team were more concerned about their own reputation than about the fate of captain Philips. A bit sad, perhaps, but logical nonetheless: every single top politician first thinks about him- or herself. Especially when something bad happens.

Should politicians act in such a way? Of course not. But it is not a perfect world. Bush, Bush, Reagan, Ford, Nixon and Eisenhower would have done exactly the same, as would Clinton, Carter, LBJ, and JFK.

  1. Posted by c3
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #90275
    c3 Shouldn't there be, say, a 48 hour moratorium on political spin? Can't we just celebrate the rescue of the Captain and then after more detail is out, discuss the parts played and credit due?
  2. Michael van der Galien No. This ain't the New Media c3. It's interpretation right-a-way.
  3. Posted by Garland
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #90284
    Garland c3's idea is something to strive for, but I am just pretty indifferent about the affair. Sure its nice that the captain was spared, but I cant see the political implications being all that significant. Obama made the assessment that some attempt at negotiation wasn't an indulgence, and when that didn't work he signed something and let the navy handle it. Whether the result of such a game plan were to lead to success or failure, I can't see Obama having much credibility to lose or win, really.
  4. Posted by Gaius
    | Quote | Trackback | Link #90331
    Gaius Michael, My personal ideal of what a president should have said in this case: "Yes, I authorized the use of force. The Captain of the Bainbridge had my full confidence and backing and did what was necessary when the situation called for action." End of statement. End of spin. A leader delegates, then immunizes his subordinates from blame after a decision is made. A leader does not grab credit afterward. Gaius